Issue Details (XML | Word | Printable)

Key: JSR348-147
Type: Bug Bug
Status: Closed Closed
Resolution: Fixed
Priority: Major Major
Assignee: eduardo
Reporter: sean_sheedy
Votes: 0
Watchers: 0
Operations

If you were logged in you would be able to see more operations.
jsr348

Give PMO ability to investigate and act on voting fraud with certain conditions

Created: 21/Sep/11 06:10 PM   Updated: 30/Sep/11 07:32 PM   Resolved: 30/Sep/11 07:32 PM
Component/s: Process Doc
Affects Version/s: None
Fix Version/s: None

Time Tracking:
Not Specified

Tags:
Participants: eduardo, pcurran and sean_sheedy


 Description  « Hide

Process Document review

line numbers: JCP-2.8-21SEP2011-Redlined.pdf

785-789 - See comments on 54, above (filed as JSR-348-133). I thought we agreed to eliminate this in the NJ EC meeting by agreeing to give the Chair power to investigate and act on voting fraud as long as evidence is clear and this activity is put in the public record. I do not see that in this document.

PC> Good catch. Please log an issue so we don't forget this again. If you can make specific suggestions for changes in language that would be helpful too.



sean_sheedy added a comment - 21/Sep/11 06:31 PM

Related:

815-817 - strike "except that Agents of JCP Members" as we decided that the PMO would be able to deal with election fraud (see 785-789 comment above.)

PC> And see my response above.

SS> Please strike this as the power to investigate as described above eliminates the need for this.


pcurran added a comment - 27/Sep/11 09:24 PM

I deleted "or if one or more Members are Agents of another Member" from "All JCP Members are eligible to vote in ballots for Ratified and Elected Seats subject to the provision that if a Member has majority-ownership of one or more other Members, or if one or more Members are Agents of another Member, then that group of Members shall collectively have one vote"

I added the following paragraph:

"If the PMO has reason to believe that an organization is attempting to influence the outcome of an election by encouraging its Agents to vote on its behalf it should take all necessary corrective action and then report the matter to the EC for approval."


pcurran added a comment - 29/Sep/11 03:14 PM

OK to strike the clause.

New para should read:

"If the PMO has reason to believe that an organization is attempting to influence the outcome of an election by instructing its Agents how to vote the PMO should take all necessary corrective action and then report the matter to the EC for approval."

Approved at September 29 WG meeting.


pcurran added a comment - 29/Sep/11 09:26 PM

See last comment


pcurran added a comment - 29/Sep/11 09:30 PM

Fixed


pcurran added a comment - 29/Sep/11 10:18 PM

Please make the changes suggested in the last comment.


eduardo added a comment - 30/Sep/11 07:32 PM

I have implemented it.