1. jsr358
  2. JSR358-9

Licensing can be withdrawn before natural expiration of copyrights/patents


    • Type: Bug Bug
    • Status: Open
    • Priority: Major Major
    • Resolution: Unresolved
    • Component/s: Licensing
    • Labels:


      Process Document review

      line numbers: JCP-2.8-21SEP2011-Redlined.pdf

      288 - "Lifetime" is a new term that implies that a JSR can be end-of-lifed and the license revoked. Strike "During the lifetime of the JSR the"

      PC> Already fixed in a later draft

      SS> I see the wording has been changed to "For as long as a JSR is licensed". This still implies that there is a lifetime. Contrast this to open source licenses like Apache or GPL which do not withdraw licenses except under specific situations; licenses like BSD have no lifetime; they expire only when the original copyright expires and the work goes into the public domain. We're not talking open source even here, but open platform. Text like this that implies that there is a lifetime provides an opportunity to spec leads to withdraw licenses. This could occur, for example, if the spec lead is offering a new technology and wishes to prevent licensing of the original JSR because implementations of it would compete with them. The work would then not be available until patents expire (20 or more years) or the copyright on the RI/TCK expires (much longer, and potentially boundless if "Mickey Mouse" extensions of copyright lifetimes are legislated.)

      Fix by requiring spec lead to provide license until work(s) fall under public domain. This highlights an area where the JCP deviates from open principles.

        Issue Links


          sean_sheedy created issue -
          pcurran made changes -
          Field Original Value New Value
          Tags Defer
          pcurran made changes -
          Project jsr348 [ 12019 ] jsr358 [ 12683 ]
          Key JSR348-138 JSR358-9
          Component/s Licensing [ 14513 ]
          Component/s Process Doc [ 13866 ]
          pcurran made changes -
          Tags Defer
          pcurran made changes -
          Link This issue is related to JSR358-34 [ JSR358-34 ]


            • Assignee:
            • Votes:
              0 Vote for this issue
              0 Start watching this issue


              • Created: