|<< Back to previous view|
[JSR348-151] minor changes Created: 21/Sep/11 Updated: 29/Sep/11 Resolved: 22/Sep/11
|Component/s:||Process Doc, Standing Rules|
|Remaining Estimate:||Not Specified|
|Time Spent:||Not Specified|
|Original Estimate:||Not Specified|
|Participants:||pcurran and sean_sheedy|
following are minor changes per email correspondence from Patrick today.
27/28 - redundant, and discourages use of rules when they should be used. strike last sentence and replace with "In certain situations it may be necessary and appropriate to resort to formal procedure when attempts to achieving progress via informal agreement have failed."
PC> Agreed. Please add to the Minor Changes issue.
110 - Replace "in the extreme and undesirable case, an EC member may not vote at all" with "EC Members should make every attempt to vote."
PC> Sounds reasonable to me. Please add to the Minor Changes issue.
119 - add to this, words that record not only the result, but which way each EC Member voted.
PC> Agreed, and this was the intent. Please add to the Minor Changes issue.
143 - record not just totals, but who voted which way.
PC> Agreed, as stated above. Please add to the Minor Changes issue.
Process Document review
line numbers: JCP-2.8-21SEP2011-Redlined.pdf
220-222 Strike last sentence. It appears to discuss "private information" in a paragraph about "Confidential materials". It also encourages private operation by an EG.
PC> I'm OK with striking the sentence - it doesn't add anything significant.
|Comment by pcurran [ 22/Sep/11 01:15 PM ]|
I've made all of the suggested changes, though in the case of the Standing Rules not necessarily in the words suggested by the submitter.
|Comment by pcurran [ 29/Sep/11 09:28 PM ]|