Java.net JIRA

jsr348
Updated descending, then Priority descending, then Created ascending
1138 of 138 as at: 28/Aug/15 3:34 AM
T Key Summary Assignee Reporter P Status Resolution Created Updated Due
Bug JSR348-156

platform comaptibility requirements for new specs unclear

Unassigned Bill Shannon Minor Open Unresolved  
Bug JSR348-153

Licensor Name Space is not formally defined

Unassigned pcurran Trivial Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-93

Comments on the Standing Rules from Anish Karmarkar

eduardo pcurran Minor Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-120

Should the JSR Review period always be four weeks, or 2-4 weeks at the option of the submitter?

eduardo pcurran Minor Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-147

Give PMO ability to investigate and act on voting fraud with certain conditions

eduardo sean_sheedy Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-128

any member can call for a vote to clarify "agreement".

pcurran sean_sheedy Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-119

Should a transfer ballot include the terms on which the new owner of the JSR intends to license it?

pcurran pcurran Minor Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-129

EC votes are just advice? problem: advice can be ignored

Unassigned sean_sheedy Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-124

private session should be agreed to by EC

Unassigned sean_sheedy Major Closed Works as designed  
Bug JSR348-111

Clarify that agenda items marked For Action cannot be modified during the meeting, and new For Action items cannot be added

pcurran pcurran Minor Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-94

Spec leads can end-of-life a Specification, withdraw licenses

pcurran sean_sheedy Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-89

Make the list of Definitions more like an index, with "virtual entries" pointing to others

pcurran pcurran Minor Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-151

minor changes

pcurran sean_sheedy Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-126

rules around missing F2F meetings

eduardo sean_sheedy Major Closed Won't Fix  
Bug JSR348-56

Define the the time-out periods

Unassigned pcurran Minor Closed Fixed  
Improvement JSR348-113

JSR Approval Ballot - definition could be clearer

pcurran Bill Shannon Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-130

abstentions are embodiment of agreement to disagree

pcurran sean_sheedy Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-125

need third party not tied up in discussions to take minutes

Unassigned sean_sheedy Major Closed Works as designed  
Bug JSR348-134

meta-issue: lack of enforcement creates loopholes, opportunities for misuse

Unassigned sean_sheedy Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-145

RI/TCK licenses permitted that allow Ri/TCK to effectively be withdrawn by spec lead

Unassigned sean_sheedy Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-150

Seats unfilled in elections can remain unfilled for a year

Unassigned sean_sheedy Major Closed Works as designed  
Bug JSR348-131

rule that ballot topics must be discussed at EC meetings raises issues

Unassigned sean_sheedy Major Closed Won't Fix  
Bug JSR348-117

1.2.3 vs. 1.2.4

Unassigned Bill Shannon Major Closed Won't Fix  
Bug JSR348-118

profiles can be based on latest or next platform version

pcurran Bill Shannon Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-77

Sections 1.2.3 and 1.7 overlap too much and should be merged

Unassigned pcurran Minor Closed Won't Fix  
Bug JSR348-74

Refactor the balloting requirements to reduce duplication

Unassigned pcurran Major Closed Won't Fix  
Bug JSR348-34

Permit Spec Leads to submit no quarterly certification report if nothing has changed

Unassigned pcurran Minor Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-112

Clarification of obligation to offer TCK and RI licenses "for ever"

pcurran pcurran Minor Closed Fixed  
Improvement JSR348-110

List the names of EG members and their organisation affiliation on the JSR page

pcurran karianna Minor Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-109

The current definition of consensus is too vague

eduardo pcurran Minor Closed Fixed  
Improvement JSR348-108

Harmonize language with RFC 2119

eduardo eduardo Minor Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-107

It should be permissible to vote no in a Maintenance Review Ballot if an issue referenced in an earlier "conditional yes vote" has not been addressed

eduardo pcurran Minor Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-106

The Maintenance Lead may submit a written statement for consideration during a Maintenance Renewal Ballot

eduardo pcurran Minor Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-105

Clean up the Unresponsive Spec Lead section

eduardo pcurran Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-98

Ensure that Spec Lead has flexibility in logging and responding issues

eduardo pcurran Minor Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-97

Minor changes in anticipation of merging the two ECs

eduardo pcurran Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-86

Improve clarity of Member definition

eduardo Alex Buckley Minor Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-84

Should Mailing List be a defined term?

eduardo pcurran Minor Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-71

Issue Tracker should be a defined term

eduardo Bill Shannon Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-70

Simplify Maintenance Review process by eliminating Item Exception Ballot and Change Log

eduardo Bill Shannon Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-64

Should there be a limit on the number of members from a single company/organization who can join an Expert Group?

Unassigned pcurran Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-57

Distinction between JSR "ballots" and EC "votes" is still not entirely clear

Unassigned pcurran Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-133

"Agent" designation unfairly discriminates against individual members already underrepresented

Unassigned sean_sheedy Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-152

Member should not be capitalized in the Standing Rules

Unassigned pcurran Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-148

Elections: grandfather seat holder terms that began prior to EC merge

Unassigned sean_sheedy Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-140

License changes during MR require unanimous EG approval except for limited circumstances

Unassigned sean_sheedy Major Closed Won't Fix  
Bug JSR348-139

prices of licenses to be disclosed in the license terms

Unassigned sean_sheedy Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-142

Prospective EG members petitions for membership are public; appeal process for rejections

Unassigned sean_sheedy Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-136

spec lead chooses what counts as "administrative", can suppress info that should be public

Unassigned sean_sheedy Major Closed Won't Fix  
Bug JSR348-141

Change "offered for the lifetime..." to "continuously available"

Unassigned sean_sheedy Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-143

appeals process open ended; other sections need to provide appeals procedure for those areas

Unassigned sean_sheedy Major Closed Won't Fix  
Bug JSR348-146

EC as level playing field

Unassigned sean_sheedy Major Closed Won't Fix  
Bug JSR348-132

elected members terms should be grandfathered

Unassigned sean_sheedy Major Closed Won't Fix  
Bug JSR348-127

ec must vote to cancel meetings once scheduled

Unassigned sean_sheedy Major Closed Won't Fix  
Bug JSR348-122

JSR-348 changes from individual perspective

Unassigned sean_sheedy Major Closed Invalid  
Bug JSR348-114

Maintenance Review definition should reference Maintenance Lead, not Spec Lead

Unassigned Bill Shannon Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-116

public access to non-written communication must not be required

Unassigned Bill Shannon Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-83

Spec Lead v. Spec Lead Member

Unassigned Alex Buckley Major Closed Won't Fix  
Bug JSR348-79

Should the Process Document specify what is appropriate for a Maintenance Release?

pcurran pcurran Minor Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-103

Remove the notes from the Standing Rules

eduardo pcurran Minor Closed Fixed  
New Feature JSR348-96

Specifications should be directly available as HTML on the web

Unassigned Stig Inge Lea Bjørnsen Minor Closed Invalid  
Bug JSR348-68

Clarify that the JSPA is sufficient for contributions

eduardo pcurran Minor Closed Fixed  
Improvement JSR348-102

Harmonize Issue List and Issue list

Unassigned eduardo Minor Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-91

State the document version explicitly in the Executive Summary

eduardo pcurran Trivial Closed Won't Fix  
Bug JSR348-90

Do we need the defined term Release?

eduardo pcurran Minor Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-101

Bad formatting in section 6.3

eduardo pcurran Trivial Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-61

Reference the issue tracker when discussing comments on "no" votes

eduardo pcurran Minor Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-87

The definition of Profile Specification contains normative requirements that should be moved to the body of the document

Unassigned pcurran Minor Closed Won't Fix  
Bug JSR348-100

Spurious blank line in Process Document

eduardo pcurran Trivial Closed Fixed  
Improvement JSR348-95

Section 1.1.2 needs a little rewording to alleviate ambiguities

Unassigned lightguard Major Closed Fixed  
Improvement JSR348-8

The prohibition on employees of JCP Members voting or running for election as individuals doesn't go far enough

eduardo pcurran Major Closed Fixed  
Improvement JSR348-4

Should Maintenance Leads be obliged to provide the final materials within a specified time-period after Maintenance Review?

pcurran pcurran Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-32

Make the requirement to maintain a Change Log optional?

Unassigned pcurran Major Closed Fixed  
Improvement JSR348-62

Add an additional vote type to section 6 called "Conditional Yes"

Unassigned mojavelinux Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-69

The Standing Rules document should have a version number

eduardo pcurran Minor Closed Fixed  
Improvement JSR348-6

The TCK documentation must contain Compatibility Requirements

eduardo pcurran Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-29

Fix typos (pointed out by Bill Shannon)

eduardo pcurran Minor Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-48

Should the PMO be referred to as "who" or "which"?

eduardo pcurran Trivial Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-26

What happens if no agenda is published in advance?

eduardo eduardo Minor Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-85

Improve clarity in 4.2 signature tests

eduardo Alex Buckley Minor Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-82

The definition of Dormant needs clarification

eduardo Alex Buckley Minor Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-76

Minor language changes suggested by Alex Buckley

eduardo pcurran Minor Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-80

Strange artifact at the top of the Process Document

eduardo pcurran Trivial Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-78

More refactoring (into Expert Group Membership)

eduardo pcurran Minor Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-75

Restucture the Executive Summary section

eduardo pcurran Minor Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-72

Require EGs to maintain a public Document Archive

eduardo pcurran Major Closed Fixed  
Improvement JSR348-59

Simplify Mailing Lists section

eduardo starksm64 Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-36

The Item Exception Ballot process is under-specified

Unassigned pcurran Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-73

Should the process for modifying the Standing Rules document be specified in the Process Doc?

Unassigned pcurran Major Closed Won't Fix  
Bug JSR348-18

1.5.2 - Add GitHub to the list of approved collaboration software

Unassigned lincolnbaxter Major Closed Fixed  
Improvement JSR348-88

The term member under the 5 member rule needs clarification in the terms of a JUG membership

Unassigned dsline Minor Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-63

The use of the term "representatives" in the definition of Member is confusing

eduardo pcurran Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-81

"Dormant" definition mentions "life cycle"

eduardo Alex Buckley Minor Closed Duplicate  
Bug JSR348-58

Clean up and expand on the process for revising the Standing Rules

eduardo pcurran Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-60

Typos in current draft

eduardo starksm64 Minor Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-55

Typo on line 225

Unassigned pcurran Trivial Closed Fixed  
Improvement JSR348-54

Formatting of Item Exception Ballot in definitions section

Unassigned starksm64 Minor Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-40

The observers mailing list is missing messages sent to expert mail list

Unassigned starksm64 Major Closed Works as designed  
Bug JSR348-31

Contribution Agreement should be a formally-defined term

eduardo pcurran Minor Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-52

Clarify when a 2/3 majority is required to approve a new JSR

eduardo pcurran Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-53

"Reasonable increases in price" should not be considered changes in licensing terms

eduardo pcurran Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-51

When a Spec Lead withdraws the replacement should be sought from the Member company

eduardo pcurran Minor Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-25

Calculating a majority

eduardo eduardo Minor Closed Fixed  
Improvement JSR348-33

Consistency in references

eduardo eduardo Major Closed Fixed  
Improvement JSR348-41

Section numbering

eduardo eduardo Minor Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-50

Clarify the meaning of the term "release"

eduardo pcurran Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-38

Process Doc should contain a non-normative reference to the Spec Lead Guide

eduardo pcurran Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-46

Process for shutting down a JSR when the Spec Lead is unresponsive or inactive is underspecified

eduardo pcurran Minor Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-43

Suggested wording changes from Harold Ogle

eduardo pcurran Trivial Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-47

Suggested wording changes for the Standing Rules

eduardo pcurran Minor Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-49

Preparing the drafts for Public Review

eduardo pcurran Minor Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-44

Current PMO practice is to label "stalled" JSRs as Dormant. Can we retroactively apply the new JSR Renewal Ballot process?

eduardo pcurran Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-45

The new wording describing the EG membership application process omits the PMO's role (from Harold Ogle)

eduardo pcurran Major Closed Fixed  
Improvement JSR348-2

The Transfer Ballot process is under-specified

eduardo pcurran Minor Closed Fixed  
Improvement JSR348-5

Clean up wording on changes to licensing terms

eduardo pcurran Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-24

Need to set title for Process document

eduardo eduardo Minor Closed Fixed  
Improvement JSR348-30

consistency in the use of vote/ballot

eduardo eduardo Minor Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-35

Replace Maintenance Feedback alias with Issue Tracker

eduardo pcurran Minor Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-37

Lines 301-302 reference a non-existent JSR submission template

eduardo pcurran Minor Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-27

Clarify when EC decisions (or votes) are binding and when they are advisory

eduardo pcurran Major Closed Fixed  
Improvement JSR348-39

Define Consensus

eduardo eduardo Major Closed Fixed  
Improvement JSR348-7

Specify issue-tracking requirements in more detail

eduardo pcurran Major Closed Fixed  
Improvement JSR348-3

Should JSR Renewal ballots be unconditionally initiated when a JSR misses its deadline?

eduardo pcurran Minor Closed Fixed  
Improvement JSR348-1

How many consecutive meetings must an EC member miss before losing their seat?

eduardo pcurran Minor Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-23

Broaden the language permitting open discussion of TCK testing results

eduardo pcurran Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-28

Requirement to disclose licenses does not mention Spec license

eduardo pcurran Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-12

1.2.1 - Publish list of accepted TCK licences

Unassigned lincolnbaxter Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-15

1.4 - TCK should be freely available for users to run and verify their implementation of choice

Unassigned lincolnbaxter Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-13

1.4 - EG/TCK Members/Observers mailing list must be consolidated

Unassigned lincolnbaxter Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-11

1.2.1 - Apache licence should be required or promoted for Specification RI and TCK

Unassigned lincolnbaxter Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-16

1.4.3 - Reverse language referring to discussion of individual TCK test results with general public

Unassigned lincolnbaxter Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-17

1.5.2 - Allow legal council from all JCP members to contribute to review of artifacts (docs, licences, terms of use, etc.)

Unassigned lincolnbaxter Major Closed Fixed  
Improvement JSR348-10

It should be mandatory to provide maintenance releases of corresponding affected specifications

Unassigned lincolnbaxter Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-19

2.1.2 - Make annual JCP event meeting at JavaOne *truly open*

pcurran lincolnbaxter Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-20

3.2 - Agility - Signing the JSPA should done electronically

Unassigned lincolnbaxter Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-22

3.3 - Agility - Concept of maintenance release should be replaced with semi-annual release.

Unassigned lincolnbaxter Major Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-42

Typo in line 229

eduardo pcurran Trivial Closed Fixed  
Bug JSR348-21

3.2 - Agility - Expert groups must not be dispanded after final release

pcurran lincolnbaxter Major Closed Fixed